The core difference
Federally the two methods sit in different parts of the regulation: sealed bidding with IFBs is FAR Part 14, and negotiated contracting with RFPs is FAR Part 15. Sealed bidding is appropriate when the specification is complete, price can decide, and discussions are not needed. When those conditions are not met, the agency negotiates through an RFP. State and local codes draw the same line.
- IFB: fixed specification, public bid opening, award on price to the low responsive and responsible bidder, no discussions.
- RFP: evaluation criteria and weights, private evaluation, possible discussions and revised offers, award on best value (which can include lowest price technically acceptable).
What it means for how you respond
For an IFB, your effort goes into price and paperwork: an accurate takeoff, competitive pricing, a complete and signed bid form, the bid bond and every addendum acknowledged. One missing signature can lose a low bid.
For an RFP, your effort goes into the narrative: a compliant structure that mirrors the evaluation criteria, a credible approach, named staff and relevant past performance, with pricing that is competitive but defensible.