GovBidAlerts
OpenRequest for Expression of InterestInternational

Consulting services for the process evaluation of the 150-school pilot of the upper secondary (profile) education reform — Lifting Education Access and Resilience in times of Need in Ukraine Program

Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine

Due Closes in 20 daysRef. LEARN-1.1-EVAL

At a glance

What

REQUEST FOR EXPRESSIONS OF INTEREST (CONSULTING SERVICES - FIRMS SELECTION) Country: Ukraine Name of Project: Lifting Education Access and Resilience in Times of Need in Ukraine Program Grant No.: TF0C5794 Assignment Title: Consulting…

Category: Request for Expression of Interest

Where
Ukraine
Key dates
  • Posted: Nov 20, 2026
  • Deadline: Fri, Dec 11, 2026 · 2:00 PM UTC (closes in 20 days)
How to respond

Description

REQUEST FOR EXPRESSIONS OF INTEREST (CONSULTING SERVICES - FIRMS SELECTION) Country: Ukraine Name of Project: Lifting Education Access and Resilience in Times of Need in Ukraine Program Grant No.: TF0C5794 Assignment Title: Consulting services for the process evaluation of the 150-school pilot of the upper secondary (profile) education reform Reference No . (as per Procurement Plan): LEARN-1.1-EVAL Ukraine has received financing from the World Bank toward the cost of the Lifting Education Access and Resilience in Times of Need in Ukraine Program, and intends to apply part of the proceeds for consulting services.
Read more ↓
The consulting services (hereinafter – the Services) include an independent, formative, theory-based process evaluation of the new model of upper secondary (profile) education piloted in 150 pilot lyceums in the 2026/2027 school year, aimed at: establishing whether pilot inputs and activities reached the pilot schools as intended and are actually used; documenting implementation variation across schools and its associated factors; examining separately the teacher-development and school-leadership development pathways; testing the key assumptions of the Theory of Change, in particular the "money follows the teacher" mechanism, school management capacity, management-track professional development and the materials-approbation feedback loop; and generating findings and recommendations on the conditions for national scale-up of the reform. The Services include analysis of administrative and monitoring data for all 150 pilot schools, primary data collection (two survey rounds, comparative case studies in 10 schools, approximately 20 lesson observations and key-informant interviews), and a synthesis of findings and recommendations. The Consultant is expected to provide the services over a period of up to eight (8) calendar months from the date of contract signature, commencing approximately in February 2027. The required objective of the Services must be achieved by the Consultant within the agreed program and in accordance with the Ukrainian legislation, the World Bank’s policies and rules and requirements of the Terms of Reference (TOR), which is attached. Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine (hereinafter – Client/MOES) now invites eligible consulting firms (hereinafter – Consultants) to indicate their interest in providing the Services. Interested Consultants should provide information demonstrating that they have the required qualifications and relevant experience to perform the Services. The evaluation of the expressions of interest provided by the Consultants will be carried out based on the following criteria: 1. Legal status and market experience The Consultant shall be a legally registered entity or eligible consortium/joint venture in accordance with applicable procurement rules. At least five years of documented experience in applied research, programme/process evaluation, monitoring and evaluation, or comparable analytical assignments. Applied research, evaluation, or monitoring and evaluation is one of the Consultant’s core lines of business. 2. Experience in evaluation and education research The Consultant shall demonstrate successful completion, during the last five years, of at least two assignments involving process/programme evaluation, mixed-methods research, monitoring and evaluation, or comparable analytical work, including multi-site primary data collection. Experience in education-sector reform, public-sector implementation, school-level research and/or large-scale mixed-methods studies, as well as experience in projects supported by the World Bank or other international development partners, will be considered an advantage. Demonstrated operational capacity to manage multi-site data collection, research involving minors, secure data handling, bilingual reporting and wartime fieldwork constraints. Demonstrated ability to integrate administrative data with primary research and translate findings into decision-oriented recommendations. 3. Financial stability The average annual turnover of the Consultant over the last two completed financial years is at least US$115,000. Financial statements: (i) tax returns; (ii) balance sheet; (iii) certificates of completion. 4. Confirmation of qualification. The Consultant shall provide: registration documents of the legal entity and, for a consortium or joint venture, the consortium agreement or letter of intent; portfolio of completed projects, indicating for each of them the client, period, value, scope and methods; for at least one completed assignment, a short description of the multi-site data collection carried out, indicating the number of sites and respondents, the fieldwork period and the safeguarding and data-protection procedures applied; evidence of the Consultant’s capacity to prepare professional reports in Ukrainian and English, such as extracts or examples of previously prepared reports or other deliverables, or a description of the in-house or contracted language and editorial capacity available for the assignment; documents confirming qualifications: (i) a description of the Consultant’s overall capacity to mobilise the Key Experts required for the assignment (see Team composition below); (ii) certificates (if any); (iii) letters of recommendation. 5. Team composition 4.1. Capacity to mobilise Key Experts Consultants must provide a description of their overall capacity to mobilise the Key Experts required for the assignment. Key Experts: Team Leader / Process Evaluation Expert Education Policy / Upper-Secondary Reform Expert School Leadership / Implementation Expert Quantitative Research / Data Lead Qualitative Research / Case Study Lead Fieldwork / Data Management Coordinator Supporting Staff: enumerators, observers, facilitators; transcription, translation and data-processing specialists; administrative staff. At the stage of evaluating submitted expressions of interest, the qualifications and experience of Key Experts are not assessed, and the submission of a technical approach and methodology is not required. A detailed Technical Approach and Methodology, as well as detailed CVs of the Key Experts, will be requested only from the highest-ranked Consultant at the next stage of the selection process, namely the submission and evaluation of the combined technical and financial proposal. The Consultant with the highest rank will be invited to submit a combined technical and financial proposal and to participate in negotiations. Should negotiations fail, MoES shall formally close negotiations with that Consultant and may invite the next highest-ranked Consultant. This process may be repeated with subsequent ranked Consultants until negotiations are successfully concluded or the procurement process is cancelled. The attention of interested Consultants is drawn to Section III, paragraphs, 3.14, 3.16, and 3.17 of the World Bank’s «Procurement Regulations for IPF Borrowers» September 2023 with amendments of February 2025 (hereinafter – Procurement Regulations), setting forth the World Bank’s policy on conflict of interest. Consultants may associate with other firms to enhance their qualifications, but should indicate clearly whether the association is in the form of a joint venture and/or a sub-consultancy. In the case of a joint venture, all the partners in the joint venture shall be jointly and severally liable for the entire contract, if selected. In the case of foreign company, the representative office/JV/consortium with local firm should exist by the date of the Contract signing. A Consultant will be selected in accordance with the Selection Based on Consultants’ Qualifications (CQS) method described in the Procurement Regulations. Further information can be obtained at the address below during office hours from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Expressions of interest must be delivered in a written form, in Ukrainian or English, to the address below by e-mail by December 11, 2026, 2:00 pm, local time . Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine Attn: Anastasiia Sofiienko - Project Coordinator E-mail: uiherp@mon.gov.ua CC: serhiy.artemenko@uiherp.org, kateryna.kovtun@mon.gov.ua Expressions of interest to be clearly marked: «LEARN-1.1-EVAL: Expression of Interest» . TERMS OF REFERENCE Consulting services for the process evaluation of the 150-school pilot of the upper secondary (profile) education reform Contract No. LEARN-1.1-EVAL World Bank Project ID No.: P504171, Grant Number: TF0C5794 List of abbreviations AIKOM Automated Information Complex of Educational Management CMU Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine CPD Continuing Professional Development IPF Investment Project Financing LEARN The Program "Lifting Education Access and Resilience in Times of Need in Ukraine Program" MoES Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine NIO NUS Implementation Office NUS The New Ukrainian School PD Professional Development PforR Program-for-Results SO Specific Objective ToC Theory of Change UIED Ukrainian Institute of Education Development USREOU Unified State Register of Enterprises and Organizations of Ukraine . BACKGROUND Ukraine and the World Bank have signed the agreements for the Program "Lifting Education Access and Resilience in Times of Need in Ukraine Program" (hereinafter referred to as the LEARN). The objectives of the LEARN are: to (i) improve teaching and learning conditions; and (ii) to strengthen the management capacity of the education system. The total financing for the Operation is US$451 million using a combination of the World Bank's financial instruments: Program-for-Results (PforR) complemented by Investment Project Financing (IPF). The Program-for-Results (PforR) is funded by a US$235 million credit provided by Bank resources, supported by credit enhancement from the Advancing Needed Credit Enhancement for Ukraine (ADVANCE Ukraine) Trust Fund, which is backed by the Government of Japan. This is formalized under the Financing Agreement between Ukraine and the International Development Association for the Program (CREDIT NUMBER 7626-UA). An additional US$150 million is provided under the Special Program for Ukraine and Moldova Recovery (SPUR) of the International Development Association (IDA) Crisis Facility, as outlined in the Loan Agreement between Ukraine and the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development for the Program (LOAN NUMBER 9721-UA). Financing Agreement (Additional Financing: Lifting Education Access and Resilience in Times of Need in Ukraine Program) between Ukraine and the International Development Association (CREDIT NUMBER 7905-UA) was signed in the amount of US$4.9 million. Furthermore, US$30 million in Investment Project Financing (IPF) is secured under the Grant Agreement between Ukraine and the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development and the International Development Association, acting as the administrator of the Ukraine Relief, Recovery, Reconstruction, and Reform Multi-Donor Trust Fund (URTF GRANT NUMBER TF0C5794). Furthermore, US$31.1 million in Additional Financing is provided through grant resources, consisting of US$30.0 million from the Ukraine Relief, Recovery, Reconstruction, and Reform Multi-Donor Trust Fund and US$1.1 million from the Global Partnership for Education Fund. This additional financing is formalized under the Grant Agreement between Ukraine and the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development and the International Development Association, jointly acting as a Supervising Entity for the Global Partnership for Education Fund and as administrator of the Ukraine Relief, Recovery, Reconstruction, and Reform Multi-Donor Trust Fund (URTF GRANT NUMBER TF0D0612; GPE GRANT NUMBER TF0D0613), and supports activities related to the continued implementation of the Program. LEARN was developed to address critical challenges and provide essential support to the education sector, aligning with the Ministry of Education and Science's (MoES) Strategic Action Plan. The Operation will focus on supporting the Strategic Action Plan Priority 2: School education and the New Ukrainian School (NUS). The continuation of the NUS reform is a key priority of the MoES. The objectives of the Operation are to (i) improve teaching and learning conditions; and (ii) strengthen management capacity of the education system. For this program, "teaching and learning conditions" refer to three critical factors of education service delivery: safety, including shelters as a pre-condition for schools to open for in-person learning and free and inclusive school bus transportation for students living further distances from schools; learning materials, especially updated textbooks and age-appropriate learning materials in line with the NUS model; and teachers trained on NUS standards, principles, and the use of the updated learning materials. Meanwhile, "management capacity of the education system" refers to institutional capabilities to plan, allocate, and monitor resources based on robust data at the student and school levels. The NUS Implementation Office (NIO) was established by the Ministry as an advisory and consultative body. The NIO's primary purpose is to support and implement the New Ukrainian School (NUS) reform by providing expert guidance, strategic oversight, and coordination of reform initiatives across Ukraine. II. OBJECTIVES AND EVALUATION QUESTIONS Overall objective The overall objective of the assignment is to assess how and under what conditions the inputs and activities of the upper-secondary pilot are delivered and translated into early changes in practice across the 150 pilot lyceums, and to generate evidence for adjustments to the pilot and national scale-up. All eight evaluation thematic areas shall receive descriptive coverage, while in-depth theory-based analysis shall focus on a limited set of priority mechanisms: the money-follows-the-teacher mechanism, school management capacity, management-track professional development, and the materials-approbation feedback loop. The Consultant may propose a justified adjustment to this set at inception, subject to Client approval. The process evaluation is formative and theory-based. It is not an impact evaluation: learning outcomes are not yet observable at meaningful scale, and the estimation of the effect of the pilot on student outcomes is outside the scope of this assignment. The evaluation shall produce practical findings during the 2026/2027 school year, while adjustments to the pilot and the preparation of the national roll-out are still possible. Specific objectives SO1. For each evaluation thematic area, establish whether inputs reached the 150 lyceums as intended and were actually usable, distinguishing formal or administrative delivery from verified receipt and use. SO2. Document implementation variation in early changes in practice across the pilot lyceums and identify plausible drivers associated with implementation practices, management decisions, and structural or contextual conditions. SO3. Examine separately how teacher-level and principal/school leadership-level development are functioning, given that they rely on different inputs, delivery mechanisms (training tracks) and assumptions. SO4. Test the assumptions of the Theory of Change, prioritising those that are currently unverified or contested (in particular the four priority mechanisms defined in the overall objective: the "money follows the teacher" mechanism, school management capacity, management-track professional development and the speed of the materials-approbation feedback loop). SO5. Assess what the implementation-variation findings imply for national scale-up, including which enabling conditions are essential, which constraints can be addressed through additional support or adaptation, and which represent structural limits to the current model. Key evaluation questions The evaluation shall answer the following five key evaluation questions. The detailed guiding questions by ToC level and evaluation thematic area, with their links to the specific objectives, their priority level and their primary evidence level, are set out in Annex 2. To what extent have the planned inputs and delivery activities in each evaluation thematic area reached the pilot schools and intended participants on time, and to what extent are they usable and actually used? What early changes in practice can be observed in the pilot schools, how do they vary between schools, and what plausible implementation, management, structural or contextual factors are associated with that variation? How are the teacher-development and the principal/school-leadership development pathways functioning, how do they differ, and how do they interact at school level? Which key assumptions and mechanisms of the Theory of Change hold in practice, in particular the four priority mechanisms ("money follows the teacher", school management capacity, management-track professional development and the materials-approbation feedback loop) and the governance and support cascade,, and which local adaptations preserve or weaken the model? Which enabling conditions are essential, which constraints can be compensated through additional support or adaptation, which represent structural limits to the current model, and what does this imply for the national scale-up? Upper secondary (profile) education pilot context From the 2026/2027 school year, 150 lyceums (hereinafter – pilot schools) selected on a competitive basis are piloting the new model of profile upper secondary education in accordance with the CMU Resolution No. 1058 and the relevant MoES order 1127 from 13.07.2026. Several components of the model are introduced at the same time: legal and regulatory framework, including the requirement to provide profile choice across three clusters within each community; curricula matching the tracks (profiles) selected by the pilot schools; professional development for teachers, including virtual accounts under the "money follows the teacher" mechanism (MoES Order No. 434); a separate management track of professional development for principals and school leadership teams; new programmes and teaching and learning materials piloted together with the UIED; investment in infrastructure, STEM equipment and staffing of the pilot schools; coordination mechanisms run by the NIO, including regular coordination meetings with the pilot schools. This is the first time the multi-component model is implemented at scale. The earlier pre-pilot in 30 schools was voluntary and not representative. Decisions on the national roll-out of profile education from the 2027/2028 school year require evidence not only on whether the model is delivered, but also on what works, for whom, under which conditions and why. The MoES already has an administrative and monitoring database on the pilot, including school selection records, institutional identifiers in AIKOM, records of teacher training from the Vector platform, equipment delivery records, and minutes of NIO coordination meetings. The pilot Theory of Change (summarised in Annex 1) defines the expected results chain and key assumptions. Known limitations Bidders should assume the following limitations, which the evaluation is expected to address only to the extent specified in these Terms of Reference: Vector records show completion of teacher training but are not linked to the subjects those teachers teach, while the grades they teach and their school affiliations in most cases may be devised, some in a non-trivial way (USREOU-AIKOM identifier mapping); participant-to-school linkage for the management track has not yet been confirmed against the full pilot list; equipment records document delivery, not installation, functionality or actual use; minutes of NIO coordination meetings record requests and decisions but are not independent verification of implementation; interoperability of AIKOM’s school and teacher identifiers with other systems cannot be assumed (see Annex 3, Section B.1, Data linkage). The Client will provide or facilitate access to these sources at the start of the assignment. Primary data collection should be priced only for the evidence gaps identified in these Terms of Reference, not for reconstruction of administrative data. These sources provide evidence on formal delivery but do not systematically establish actual use, changes in practice, or the reasons for variation in implementation across schools. The evaluation shall therefore complement and triangulate existing data to assess how the pilot is implemented in practice and to identify the implementation-related and structural or contextual factors associated with variation, including unresolved school-network arrangements. Classroom teaching practices in the pilot schools are also measured under the parallel assignment LEARN-2.4-TEACH, which applies the Teach Secondary classroom observation tool). The process evaluation shall use relevant instruments and data from that assignment and avoid duplication (see Component 3).Because the Teach Secondary tool does not define track-specific expectations, it may not show whether teaching meets the requirements of the basic and advanced tracks; the Consultant shall therefore complement it with a supplementary track-specific observation module (see Annex 3, Section B.3) The Consultant will be contracted in line with the World Bank Procurement Regulations. These Terms of Reference define the purpose, scope and duration of the consulting services and the qualification requirements for the Consultant. III. SCOPE OF SERVICES This section summarises what is procured, in what volume and in what form. The detailed methodological specification is set out in Annex 3, which forms an integral part of these Terms of Reference. The five specific objectives and five key evaluation questions remain the governing framework, but the depth of analysis shall be differentiated: all eight evaluation thematic areas receive descriptive coverage, while the core questions and priority mechanisms identified in Annex 2 receive in-depth treatment. Exact sequencing and operational details may be refined in the Inception Report, subject to Client approval. Summary of the services The Client procures an independent process evaluation that consists of: an inception package that turns the Theory of Change and the evaluation questions into an agreed evaluation matrix, methodology and set of instruments (Component 1); a system-wide implementation profile of all 150 pilot schools, based mainly on existing data (Component 2); primary data collection: two survey rounds, comparative case studies in 10 schools, 20 lesson observations and a limited number of key-informant interviews (Component 3); a comparative analysis of implementation variation, mechanisms and assumptions (Component 4); a synthesis with scale-up conditions and prioritised recommendations, an interim learning session and a final workshop (Component 5). The services are delivered through four deliverables over up to eight months and a final data package (Section IV). Evaluation framework The evaluation covers four levels of the Theory of Change (Annex 1): (1) inputs, (2) delivery activities, (3) changes in practice and (4) intermediate outcomes (cross-cutting). It covers the following eight evaluation thematic areas: legal and regulatory framework; curriculum and student choice; teacher development; principal and school-leadership development; content and materials; infrastructure and resources; governance, monitoring and coordination; student and family experience. Annex 2 provides guiding evaluation questions and identifies their priority and primary evidence level. The Consultant may refine or consolidate secondary questions during inception, subject to Client approval, provided that the five key evaluation questions, core questions and priority mechanisms remain covered. Component 1. Inception and operationalisation of the evaluation framework The Consultant shall review the Theory of Change, available pilot documentation, monitoring instruments, administrative datasets and existing evidence, and translate the agreed evaluation questions into a detailed, feasible and auditable evaluation framework. The inception package shall include: an evaluation matrix linking objectives, evaluation questions, ToC levels, evaluation thematic areas, indicators or evidence criteria, data sources, analytical methods and deliverables; working definitions of the key terms used in the evaluation (e.g., implementation fidelity, receipt, usability, use, adaptation, enabling conditions, compensable constraints, structural limits); a rapid audit of available administrative and monitoring data, including their completeness and linkability; a separate mapping of the teacher-development and school-leadership development pathways; the mixed-methods methodology, analytical plan, sampling strategy and fieldwork schedule; piloted data-collection instruments (survey questionnaires, interview and focus-group guides, document-review templates and classroom-observation protocols); ethics, safeguarding, data-management, security and remote-fieldwork procedures; an inception workshop with the Client. Detailed requirements: Annex 3, Section B.1. Component 2. System-wide assessment of delivery, reach and use across the 150 pilot schools The Consultant shall prepare an implementation profile for all 150 pilot schools across the eight evaluation thematic areas, using existing administrative, monitoring, documentary and survey evidence. Wherever data permit, the profile shall distinguish what was planned or formally provided, what was received, what was operational or usable, and what was actually used. The profile shall support descriptive and disaggregated analysis, the identification of implementation patterns and the selection of contrasting case-study schools. It shall not be reduced to a simple school ranking or performance score unless a valid measurement approach is approved by the Client. Detailed requirements: Annex 3, Section B.2. Component 3. Primary stakeholder research and direct verification The Consultant shall collect primary evidence sufficient to verify implementation and explain stakeholder experience where administrative reporting is incomplete or cannot establish actual use or practice. Primary data collection shall complement, not duplicate, existing monitoring. The expected volume of primary data collection is set out below. Exact sample sizes shall be proposed by the Consultant and approved in the Inception Report within these parameters. The design shall prioritise decision value and feasibility, avoid unnecessary respondent tracking, and limit quantitative disaggregation to a small number of priority dimensions. Method/source Indicative coverage Frequency Administrative/documentary system-wide profile All 150 pilot schools One consolidated profile, updated as data become available School administration survey Seek all 150 schools 2 rounds (panel where feasible) Teacher survey Statistically adequate sample across the pilot cohort, designed around up to three priority disaggregation dimensions 2 repeated cross-sectional rounds Student survey Statistically adequate sample across the pilot cohort, designed around up to three priority disaggregation dimensions 2 repeated cross-sectional rounds Parent/caregiver module Targeted sample focused on information, choice, transition and access 1 round Founder/hromada structured data collection Targeted sample linked to case-study and priority implementation contexts 1 round Comparative case studies 10 schools Main fieldwork + limited remote follow-up in up to 5 schools Classroom observations Approx. 20 lessons across ≥5 case-study schools Main fieldwork National/subnational key-informant interviews Limited purposive sample of national actors, selected subnational actors directly relevant to priority mechanisms, and up to 3 relevant teacher-training providers Main fieldwork School/facility walkthrough/direct verification Relevant case-study schools where safe and feasible Main fieldwork The Consultant shall review the instruments and data of the parallel assignment LEARN-2.4-TEACH, use or adapt them where methodologically appropriate, and complement them with a concise supplementary module defining the intended competency-based and differentiated teaching practices for the basic and advanced tracks (see Annex 3, Section B.3). Classroom observations are case-study and mechanism-verification evidence and are not representative of the full pilot. All primary evidence shall be triangulated with administrative, documentary and observational evidence. Detailed requirements: Annex 3, Section B.3. Component 4. Comparative analysis of implementation variation, mechanisms and assumptions The Consultant shall combine the 150-school profile with the primary evidence to explain why implementation succeeds or encounters difficulties under different conditions. The analysis shall in particular: compare schools with different levels of enabling conditions, without making causal claims that are not supported by the design; assess teacher development and school-leadership development as distinct but interacting pathways, and school management capacity as a cross-cutting mechanism; test the priority mechanisms defined in Section II ("money follows the teacher", school management capacity, management-track PDthe materials-approbation feedback loop); analyse the implementation-support cascade, including the role of founders/hromadas and of the coordination mechanisms; distinguish implementation-fidelity problems, structural or contextual constraints, legitimate adaptations, adaptations that weaken the model, and design assumptions that require system-level revision. Detailed requirements: Annex 3, Section B.4. Component 5. Synthesis, scale-up recommendations and knowledge transfer The Consultant shall integrate all evidence into a coherent assessment of implementation and its implications for the national scale-up, including: a clear answer to each of the five key evaluation questions and specific objectives; a classification of scale-up conditions into essential enabling conditions, constraints that can be compensated through additional support or adaptation, and structural limits to the current model; identification of the components that can be scaled as designed, require modification or require differentiated approaches by context; prioritised recommendations addressed to national bodies, oblast/regional actors, founders/hromadas and schools; a limited set of priority indicators and data sources for monitoring after the evaluation, with suggested owners and frequency; an interim learning session and a final dissemination/decision workshop with the Client and key stakeholders. Detailed requirements: Annex 3, Section B.5. Scope boundaries The assignment is a process/implementation evaluation. It shall be designed to maximise decision value within the available time and financial envelope, using existing data for full-cohort coverage and concentrating resource-intensive fieldwork on analytically selected cases. The following activities are outside the mandatory scope: a stand-alone causal impact evaluation using a non-pilot control group, matching or difference-in-differences; design and implementation of a separate diagnostic assessment of student learning outcomes; redevelopment of the reform Theory of Change from first principles; comprehensive in-person fieldwork in all 150 pilot schools; creation of a permanent public dashboard or web platform for monitoring; longitudinal tracking beyond the contract period. The Consultant may, at no additional cost, undertake limited analysis of learning-outcome, diagnostic or comparison data generated by parallel initiatives if such data are readily available and directly relevant to the evaluation questions. This analysis is optional, shall not require additional primary data collection, and is not an expected deliverable. The methodology, sampling design, fieldwork plan and staffing proposed by the Consultant shall be feasible within the maximum contract value specified in the procurement documents. The Consultant shall demonstrate the corresponding level of effort and allocation of resources in its technical proposal. Any material expansion of the agreed scope shall require prior written approval by the Client and, where applicable, a contract amendment. IV. DELIVERABLES, TIMELINE AND PAYMENT The indicative duration of the assignment is up to eight (8) months from contract signature. Exact dates shall be aligned with the school calendar and confirmed during inception. The Consultant shall submit all deliverables electronically. Substantive reports shall be provided in English and Ukrainian unless otherwise agreed with the Client. Data collection in schools shall be scheduled within the school year and coordinated with the Client to avoid overloading the pilot schools, including with the LEARN-2.4-TEACH fieldwork. The workplan shall allow sufficient time before the early survey round for approval of the research-ethics and data-protection protocol (Annex 3, Section D) and for obtaining parental/guardian consent and student assent, organised through the pilot schools with the support of the Client. The follow-up survey round shall be completed before the end of the school year; if the contract start date does not allow this, deliverable dates shall be adjusted at inception, subject to Client approval. Deliverable Core content Due date Review / acceptance Payment D1. Inception Report and Evaluation Package Final evaluation matrix with core/secondary priorities and primary evidence levels; data-source audit; confirmed teacher/leadership pathway mapping; methodology and analysis plan; sampling strategy; survey plan (linked rounds for school administration where feasible, repeated cross-sections for teachers and students, one round for parents/caregivers and founders); case-study sampling strategy and selection criteria; indicative observation plan and supplementary track-specific observation module; draft/final instruments; ethics, safeguarding and data-management plan; detailed workplan and risk register. Within 5 weeks Approval after inception workshop and incorporation of consolidated comments. 15% D2. Delivery and Early Implementation Report System-wide 150-school profile; results of early survey round; verified delivery/reach/use findings; teacher- and leadership-development coverage; governance/data-flow review; key evidence gaps; confirmed case-study sample; management briefing. By end of Month 4 Report, data tables and briefing approved by Client. 25% D3. Comparative Implementation and Mechanisms Report Qualitative case-study evidence; classroom observations; cross-case analysis; preliminary testing of mechanisms/assumptions; support-cascade analysis; emerging adaptations, bottlenecks and enabling conditions; interim learning session. By end of Month 6 Interim report and presentation approved after learning session. 25% D4. Final Process Evaluation and Scale-up Package Follow-up quantitative analysis; integrated synthesis; answers to all five evaluation questions; final mechanism/variation analysis; essential/compensable/structural scale-up conditions; prioritised recommendations; executive summary; final presentation; complete anonymised data and documentation package. By end of Month 8 Final package approved following presentation and incorporation of consolidated comments. 35% The Client should normally provide one consolidated set of comments within ten (10) working days of receipt of each substantive deliverable. The Consultant shall address agreed comments within a timeframe specified by the Client, normally within five (5) working days for D1–D3 and ten (10) working days for D4. Short monthly progress updates and coordination calls are part of contract management and do not constitute separate paid deliverables. Payments shall be made upon the Client’s acceptance of the respective deliverable, confirmed by a signed Certificate of Acceptance. Final data package In addition to the formal deliverables above, the Consultant shall hand over a complete and usable evaluation package to the Client. The final package shall include: final reports and executive summaries in editable Word format and PDF; presentation deck(s) for decision-makers and stakeholders; final survey questionnaires, interview/focus-group guides, observation protocols and document-review tools; cleaned and anonymised quantitative datasets in an agreed open or commonly used format, with codebooks and variable dictionaries; anonymised or appropriately de-identified qualitative evidence and coding framework, subject to consent and confidentiality constraints; analysis syntax/scripts and derived-indicator documentation where applicable; case-selection and sampling documentation; a concise monitoring-continuation note identifying priority indicators, sources, owners and recommended frequency; a log of material data-quality issues, evidence gaps and limitations that should be addressed in future monitoring or evaluation. V. REQUIREMENTS FOR THE CONSULTANT General requirements The following minimum requirements shall be applied to determine the Consultant’s qualifications: 1. Legal status and market experience The Consultant shall be a legally registered entity or eligible consortium/joint venture in accordance with applicable procurement rules. At least five years of documented experience in applied research, programme/process evaluation, monitoring and evaluation, or comparable analytical assignments. Applied research, evaluation, or monitoring and evaluation is one of the Consultant’s core lines of business. 2. Experience in evaluation and education research The Consultant shall demonstrate successful completion, during the last five years, of at least two assignments involving process/programme evaluation, mixed-methods research, monitoring and evaluation, or comparable analytical work, including multi-site primary data collection. Experience in education-sector reform, public-sector implementation, school-level research and/or large-scale mixed-methods studies, as well as experience in projects supported by the World Bank or other international development partners, will be considered an advantage. Demonstrated operational capacity to manage multi-site data collection, research involving minors, secure data handling, bilingual reporting and wartime fieldwork constraints. Demonstrated ability to integrate administrative data with primary research and translate findings into decision-oriented recommendations. 3. Financial stability The average annual turnover of the Consultant over the last two completed financial years is at least US$115,000. Financial statements: (i) tax returns; (ii) balance sheet; (iii) certificates of completion. 4. Confirmation of qualification. The Consultant shall provide: registration documents of the legal entity and, for a consortium or joint venture, the consortium agreement or letter of intent; portfolio of completed projects, indicating for each of them the client, period, value, scope and methods; for at least one completed assignment, a short description of the multi-site data collection carried out, indicating the number of sites and respondents, the fieldwork period and the safeguarding and data-protection procedures applied; evidence of the Consultant’s capacity to prepare professional reports in Ukrainian and English, such as extracts or examples of previously prepared reports or other deliverables, or a description of the in-house or contracted language and editorial capacity available for the assignment; documents confirming qualifications: (i) a description of the Consultant’s overall capacity to mobilise the Key Experts required for the assignment (see Team composition below); (ii) certificates (if any); (iii) letters of recommendation. At the Expression of Interest (EOI) submission stage, the qualifications of Key Experts are not evaluated, and the submission of a technical approach and methodology is not required. A detailed Technical Approach and Methodology, as well as detailed CVs of the Key Experts, will be requested only from the highest-ranked Consultant at the next stage of the selection process, namely, the submission and evaluation of the Combined Technical and Financial Proposals. Team composition The Consultant shall propose the Key Experts listed below. One Key Expert may cover more than one role where justified and where this does not compromise quality, independence or workload feasibility. The Consultant may engage additional non-key experts and support personnel as necessary for the delivery of the assignment. The need for such expertise, including the proposed roles and level of effort, shall be specified in the Inception Report. Only the Key Experts listed below are assessed during the evaluation of proposals. The CVs of the Key Experts shall be submitted with the combined technical and financial proposal and will be assessed during the evaluation of proposals. Each CV shall indicate the education (degree, institution and year), the relevant assignments completed and the role performed in each of them. Key expert/Role Minimum profile Primary responsibility Team Leader / Process Evaluation Expert At least 8 years of relevant experience; demonstrated leadership of mixed-methods or theory-based evaluations; expertise in Theory of Change, process/implementation evaluation and policy synthesis. At least a Master’s degree in public policy, education, economics, social sciences, evaluation, or another relevant field. A PhD or equivalent doctoral degree in a relevant field is an advantage. Overall methodology, quality assurance, client liaison, integration of findings and final recommendations. Education Policy / Upper-Secondary Reform Expert At least 3 years in education policy, school reform, curriculum/teacher policy, education management or comparable fields. At least a Master’s degree in education, education policy, public administration, social sciences or another relevant field. Knowledge of Ukrainian secondary education is strongly preferred. Interpretation of reform design, curriculum/student-choice pathway, system implications and recommendations. School Leadership / Implementation Expert At least 3 years of relevant experience in school leadership, organisational change, education management or implementation support. At least a Master’s degree in education management, public administration, organisational development, social sciences or another relevant field. Leadership-development pathway, management-capacity assessment, school organisation, support cascade and founder-school interaction. Quantitative Research / Data Lead At least 3 years of survey research and quantitative analysis; ability to work with administrative datasets and document reproducible analysis. At least a Master’s degree in statistics, sociology, economics, data science or another relevant field. Sampling, questionnaires, data quality, descriptive/disaggregated analysis and data linkage. Qualitative Research / Case Study Lead At least 3 years in interviews, focus groups, comparative case studies and thematic analysis; process tracing/contribution analysis desirable. At least a Master’s degree in sociology, social anthropology, psychology, education or another relevant field. Case-study design, qualitative instruments, fieldwork quality, coding and mechanism analysis. Fieldwork / Data Management Coordinator At least 3 years of demonstrated experience coordinating multi-site research, consent/safeguarding procedures, data security and logistics in Ukraine. Fieldwork coordination, secure data handling, scheduling, respondent protection and documentation. The Consultant shall have strong Ukrainian-language capacity and sufficient English-language capacity to produce professional deliverables in both languages. The Consultant is responsible for any additional enumerators, observers, facilitators, transcription, translation, data-processing or administrative staff required to complete the assignment. Capacity to deliver professional outputs in both languages is a contract requirement; evidence of this capacity shall be provided as set out in the General requirements above. VI. IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS Responsibilities of the Consultant mobilise and manage the evaluation team and supporting personnel; provide all logistics, travel, communications, software, equipment, transcription, translation and other inputs required for the Services; develop and implement a feasible security-aware fieldwork plan, including remote alternatives where in-person work is unsafe or impossible; maintain the independence and integrity of the evaluation and transparently document limitations, conflicting evidence and analytical judgements; coordinate closely with the Client and New Ukrainian School Implementation Office (NIO) while retaining responsibility for technical decisions and quality of analysis; obtain required informed consent/assent and comply with approved safeguarding and data-protection procedures; maintain secure storage and controlled access to raw data; incorporate consolidated Client / NIO comments while preserving an auditable record of material analytical decisions. Responsibilities of the Client provide the final Theory of Change and relevant policy, legal, implementation and monitoring documentation available to the Client; provide or facilitate access to available pilot datasets, administrative extracts, school identifiers, monitoring instruments and implementation records, subject to legal and confidentiality requirements; provide the definitive list of pilot schools and relevant school/community contacts; facilitate access to teacher-development and management-track professional-development records and participant-to-school linkage where available; issue or facilitate official communication to pilot schools and relevant authorities to support participation; designate a focal point for day-to-day coordination and consolidate feedback from relevant stakeholders; facilitate coordination with parallel initiatives that may produce relevant evidence, including learning assessments or other monitoring streams; review deliverables and provide consolidated feedback within the agreed timelines. VII. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Coordination and learning The assignment shall include regular coordination with the Client through NIO, an inception workshop, an interim learning session and a final presentation/decision workshop. These sessions are intended to clarify evidence, test interpretation and support use of findings. Stakeholder validation shall not be treated as a requirement to alter independently supported findings. Ethics, safeguarding and data protection The Consultant shall apply appropriate ethical and safeguarding standards for research involving students, teachers, parents/caregivers and education personnel. Before primary data collection, the Consultant shall submit for approval a research-ethics and data-protection protocol that meets the minimum requirements set out in Annex 3, Section D. Raw personally identifiable data shall be accessible only to authorised Consultant personnel and approved subcontractors or subprocessors strictly to the extent necessary for the assignment and subject to equivalent confidentiality, safeguarding and data-protection obligations. Such data shall not be disclosed to any other third party or used for purposes outside the assignment. Anonymised evaluation data and all agreed products shall be transferred to the Client in accordance with the contract. Confidentiality, ownership and use of outputs The Client shall make available existing data, documents, reports and studies relevant to the assignment, subject to applicable access and confidentiality restrictions. The Consultant is responsible for verifying, interpreting and appropriately using such materials. The Consultant shall not disclose confidential data, documents or identifiable information to third parties not authorised under the assignment. Unless otherwise specified in the contract, all deliverables, instruments, anonymised datasets, coding frameworks, analysis scripts and other products produced under the assignment shall become the property of the Client upon acceptance and payment. Pre-existing methodologies, software, tools, templates and other intellectual property owned or licensed by the Consultant or third parties before the assignment shall remain the property of their respective rights holders. Where such materials are incorporated into an accepted deliverable, the Consultant shall ensure that the Client has sufficient rights to use that deliverable for the purposes of the assignment and subsequent reform implementation. Any public dissemination, publication or reuse of assignment data or findings by the Consultant shall require prior written approval from the Client and must comply with consent, confidentiality and data-protection requirements. Equipment No equipment shall be purchased on behalf of the Client under this assignment or transferred to the Client after its completion. Annex 1. Theory of Change EVALUATION THEMATIC AREA INPUTS DELIVERY ACTIVITIES CHANGES IN PRACTICE INTERMEDIATE OUTCOME KEY ASSUMPTIONS Legal & regulatory framework CMU Resolution 1058; MoES order naming 150 lyceums; 3-cluster requirement. Schools/founders notified; handbook and admission guidance issued. Transparent admission rules aligned with the standard. Choice is real, delivered and reversible. Necessary conditions largely self-reported; MoES→oblast→founder/school cascade may distort requirements. Curriculum & student choice Track/profile structure across three clusters; curricula matching chosen tracks. Schools open declared profiles/electives; curricula available. Students select a track and can revise during Grade 10 adaptation. Choice reflects genuine interest and access is equitable. Avoid double-counting the choice causal chain; verify declared versus delivered offer. Teacher development PD places; virtual accounts; approved CPD providers across NUS subject domains[1]. Teachers trained ahead of rollout; Vector access; funds available/used. Competency-based and differentiated teaching practices appropriate to basic and advanced track expectations. Teaching matches standard; relevant teachers are qualified for profile delivery. No complete linked dataset from PD completion to actual course assignment; money-follows-teacher assumptions contested. Principal & school-leadership development Management-track PD places; career-guidance/additional pedagogical function. Leadership teams complete management track; connected to coordination mechanism. Leaders organise profiles/timetables, reallocate staff, communicate and solve problems. Organisational capacity translates the model into practice. Management capacity not yet operationalised; management-track coverage/linkage needs confirmation. Content & materials New programmes and teaching/learning materials selected for piloting. Teachers/students have timely access to the applicable programmes and materials in accordance with the approbation and textbook-production cycle; approbation/testing operates. Materials actually used; teachers/schools cope with gaps where needed. Evidence-tested programmes/materials ready for scaling; coherent profile curriculum. Approbation feedback loop must be fast enough; school participation does not equal teacher-level coverage. Infrastructure & resources Infrastructure/STEM investment; staffing; psychosocial staff; connectivity; boarding/transport. Equipment delivered/installed; specialised hours staffed; access arrangements in place. Spaces/equipment used for profile learning; founder/community decisions support operation. Environment sustains delivery; real cost becomes known. Receipt does not prove classroom use; security and local fiscal space may constrain feasibility. Governance, monitoring & coordination NUS Implementation Office and other recurring coordination mechanisms. Requests, barriers and decisions logged and followed up. Bottlenecks flagged/escalated; evidence contributes to adjustments. Pilot evidence informs implementation and future regulation/scale-up. Monitoring obligations/data flows need confirmation; coordination records are not independent verification. Student & family experience* Information on profiles/tracks, admission and access conditions. Orientation/counselling and communication occur before choice/transition. Students/families experience informed choice, transition and access in practice. Equitable access and meaningful choice; barriers identified early. Information may arrive late; travel, school change and family circumstances may affect choice/access unevenly. Annex 2. Detailed Evaluation Matrix Core questions structure the evidence required to answer the five key evaluation questions. They relate to the priority mechanisms or to decisions required for national scale-up and receive in-depth analysis; secondary questions receive descriptive coverage and may be refined or consolidated at inception, subject to Client approval. Primary evidence level indicates the main expected source of evidence (administrative/documentary data, surveys or case studies); all findings shall still be triangulated where feasible. ToC level Evaluation thematic area Guiding evaluation question Linked objective(s) Priority Primary evidence level INPUTS Legal & regulatory Have all 150 schools received the legal/regulatory conditions needed to implement the State Standard, and is this confirmed independently rather than only through self-report? SO1 Verify delivery/use Secondary Administrative INPUTS Curriculum & student choice Do all 150 schools have curricula matching the tracks they selected, and were these available early enough to inform preparation? SO1 Verify delivery/use Secondary Administrative INPUTS Teacher development Are PD places, money-follows-the-teacher accounts and approved CPD providers reaching the teachers who actually teach the relevant grade and subject? SO1 Verify delivery/use; SO3 Teacher/leadership pathways Core Administrative INPUTS Principal / school leadership What management-track PD inputs exist for school leaders, how do they differ from the teacher track, and are they sufficient given the emerging importance of management capacity? SO3 Teacher/leadership pathways Core Administrative INPUTS Content & materials Are the new programmes and teaching/learning materials available to schools and teachers by the intended point in the annual cycle? SO1 Verify delivery/use Core Administrative INPUTS Infrastructure & resources Have infrastructure/STEM subventions, staffing allocations and relevant support posts reached schools as budgeted/planned? SO1 Verify delivery/use Secondary Administrative INPUTS Governance, monitoring & coordination Are the coordination mechanisms (including recurring MoES-pilot coordination meetings and defined data flows) and the support responsibilities assigned to founders (budgets, network decisions, administrative support) in place and operating as designed? SO1 Verify delivery/use; SO4 Test mechanisms Core Administrative INPUTS Student & family experience Do students and families receive clear and timely information about profiles/tracks, electives and selection criteria before choices are made? SO1 Verify delivery/use Secondary Survey DELIVERY Legal & regulatory Have schools and founders been formally notified, and do they report that the guidance received was usable, timely and sufficient? SO1 Verify delivery/use Secondary Survey DELIVERY Curriculum & student choice Have schools opened the declared profiles and electives for students to actually choose from? SO1 Verify delivery/use; SO2 Explain variation Secondary Administrative DELIVERY Teacher development Was teacher PD delivered as designed (fidelity), in what volume (dose) and to which relevant teachers before key implementation decisions such as timetable finalisation (reach and timing); how do participants rate its quality and usefulness; and were virtual-account funds sufficient and actually used? SO1 Verify delivery/use; SO3 Teacher/leadership pathways Core Survey DELIVERY Principal / school leadership What share of leadership teams completed the management track, and is participant-to-school linkage confirmed against the full pilot list? SO3 Teacher/leadership pathways Core Administrative DELIVERY Content & materials Do teachers and students have timely access to the materials required for the 2026/2027 pilot, including electronic and approbation materials where printed textbooks are not yet expected under the piloting cycle, and what is the actual coverage of materials testing/approbation? SO1 Verify delivery/use Core Administrative DELIVERY Infrastructure & resources Was equipment delivered, installed and verified on site, and are specialised hours covered by appropriately qualified staff without material vacancies? SO1 Verify delivery/use Secondary Administrative DELIVERY Governance, monitoring & coordination Are school requests, barriers and decisions logged systematically and comparably? When implementation problems arise, is the founder a functioning first point of contact, or do schools bypass founders and go directly to MoES? SO1 Verify delivery/use; SO4 Test mechanisms Core Case study DELIVERY Student & family experience Do schools and founders run orientation and counselling activities ahead of track selection, and do students/families report receiving them? SO1 Verify delivery/use Secondary Survey CHANGES IN PRACTICE Legal & regulatory Do schools apply transparent, standard-aligned admission rules in day-to-day practice, not only as formal documents? SO2 Explain variation; SO4 Test mechanisms Secondary Case study CHANGES IN PRACTICE Curriculum & student choice Are students selecting tracks that reflect genuine interest, and is the choice real and equitable across locations and school types? SO2 Explain variation; SO4 Test mechanisms Secondary Survey CHANGES IN PRACTICE Teacher development To what extent are the intended competency-based and differentiated teaching practices, as defined for the basic and advanced tracks in the supplementary observation module, visible in observed lessons? SO2 Explain variation; SO3 Teacher/leadership pathways Core Case study CHANGES IN PRACTICE Principal / school leadership How are leadership teams organising profiles, timetables and staff reallocation, and how does this vary with observed management capacity? SO2 Explain variation; SO3 Teacher/leadership pathways; SO4 Test mechanisms Core Case study CHANGES IN PRACTICE Content & materials Are materials actually used in lessons, and where they are missing or delayed, how are teachers and schools coping? SO2 Explain variation; SO4 Test mechanisms Core Case study CHANGES IN PRACTICE Infrastructure & resources Are spaces and equipment used in practice for profile learning, beyond simple installation or receipt? SO2 Explain variation; SO4 Test mechanisms Secondary Case study CHANGES IN PRACTICE Governance, monitoring & coordination Are bottlenecks being flagged and escalated, and do findings visibly feed into adjustments? What do directors identify as the most significant bottleneck in the support cascade? SO2 Explain variation; SO4 Test mechanisms Core Case study CHANGES IN PRACTICE Student & family experience Do students and families experience profile/track selection as real and informed? How do they experience the transition into the new structure, including school change, longer commutes and new routines, and which groups face material access barriers? SO2 Explain variation; SO4 Test mechanisms Secondary Survey INTERMEDIATE OUTCOMES Cross-cutting enabling conditions Which conditions across legal, curricular, teacher-, leadership-, resource-, governance- and student/family-related areas are essential, which can be compensated through support or adaptation, and which represent structural limits to the current model? SO5 Scale-up Core Case study INTERMEDIATE OUTCOMES Management capacity as mechanism How does school leadership/management capacity function as a cross-cutting mechanism explaining variation in intermediate outcomes across other evaluation thematic areas? SO3 Teacher/leadership pathways; SO4 Test mechanisms; SO5 Scale-up Core Case study INTERMEDIATE OUTCOMES Scale-up transferability What do implementation-variation findings imply about the conditions required for intermediate outcomes to hold when the model is scaled nationally? SO5 Scale-up Core Case study Annex 3. Detailed Methodological Requirements This Annex sets out the detailed methodological requirements for the services summarised in Section III. It forms an integral part of these Terms of Reference. A. Minimum methodological requirements The Consultant may propose the detailed design and analytical methods, but the methodology shall, at minimum: Be explicitly grounded in the agreed Theory of Change, five specific objectives, five key evaluation questions and the priority classification in Annex 2, applying lighter descriptive treatment to secondary questions and in-depth analysis to core questions and priority mechanisms. Use a mixed-methods approach combining quantitative, qualitative, administrative, documentary and direct-observation evidence. Prioritise audit, reuse and linkage of existing data before introducing new reporting requirements for schools. Triangulate self-report with independent documentary, administrative or observational evidence wherever reasonably possible. Distinguish formal delivery from verified receipt, usability/functionality and actual use. Assess both implementation fidelity and legitimate local adaptation. Analyse heterogeneity and implementation variation rather than relying only on pilot-wide averages. Examine the relative role of structural, contextual and wartime constraints and of implementation practices and management decisions in explaining variation, without making attribution claims that the design cannot support. Assess teacher development and school-leadership development separately as well as their interaction. Treat school leadership/management capacity as a construct requiring direct evidence, not as a simple proxy based on prior piloting or training attendance. Use purposive comparative sampling for qualitative case studies, informed by the implementation-variation dimensions (Section C) and updated implementation evidence. Apply appropriate statistical analysis to quantitative data and transparent thematic coding to qualitative evidence. Use contribution analysis and/or process tracing for priority mechanisms where these approaches add explanatory value. Include a transparent account of data quality, missingness, response rates, limitations, uncertainty and contradictions in the evidence. Produce reproducible and well-documented datasets, coding frameworks, indicator definitions and analysis scripts to the extent technically feasible. B. Methodological specification by component B.1. Inception and operationalisation of the evaluation framework (Component 1) The Consultant shall: Operationalise the ToC into an evaluation matrix linking objectives, evaluation questions, ToC levels, evaluation thematic areas, indicators or evidence criteria, data sources, analytical methods and deliverables. Establish clear working definitions for implementation fidelity, reach, receipt, usability, use, adaptation, enabling conditions, compensable constraints, structural limits and early intermediate outcomes. Conduct a rapid data audit covering ownership, coverage, identifiers, update frequency, completeness, quality, comparability and linkability of available administrative and monitoring sources. Confirm and separately map the teacher-development and school-leadership/management-development pathways, including training-track coverage and participant-to-school linkage. Identify evidence gaps requiring primary data collection and avoid duplicating information already available through administrative systems, existing monitoring or partner-generated data. Develop a detailed mixed-methods methodology, analytical plan, fieldwork schedule and integration strategy for quantitative, qualitative, administrative and observational evidence. Develop a purposive sampling strategy for 10 comparative case studies, including selection criteria based on the implementation-variation dimensions in Section C. The final selection of case-study schools shall be confirmed in Deliverable D2 based on the available implementation evidence. Finalise and pilot all required data-collection instruments, including survey instruments, interview/focus-group guides, document-review templates and classroom-observation protocols. Prepare data-management, safeguarding, consent, research-ethics, security and remote-fieldwork procedures. Conduct an inception workshop with the Client to confirm the evaluation matrix, samples, instruments, fieldwork approach, timeline, roles and risk-management arrangements. Data linkage. Where source systems do not contain compatible identifiers, the Consultant shall quantify the achievable linkage coverage, document the resulting analytical limitations and propose feasible remedies. Creation of new cross-system identifiers or retrospective reconstruction of missing linkages is outside the mandatory scope unless separately agreed with the Client. B.2. System-wide assessment of delivery, reach and use (Component 2) The Consultant shall create a system-wide implementation profile for all 150 pilot schools using existing administrative, monitoring, documentary and survey evidence. The profile shall support descriptive analysis, disaggregation, identification of implementation patterns and selection of contrasting cases for deeper qualitative analysis. The profile shall cover, as a minimum, the following aspects of each evaluation thematic area: Legal and regulatory framework: receipt and usability of the legal/regulatory conditions; notification of schools and founders; admission guidance; translation of national requirements into school- and community-level arrangements. Curriculum and student choice: alignment of curricula with selected tracks; opening of declared profiles and electives; organisation of profile choice, revisability, grouping and timetabling; alignment between declared and delivered offers. Teacher development: availability and timing of subject-relevant PD; reach of Vector/other approved programmes; operation and adequacy of money-follows-the-teacher virtual accounts; linkage between trained teachers and the subjects/grades they actually teach; application of competency-based and differentiated approaches. Principal and school-leadership development: management-track PD inputs and completion; participant-to-school linkage; leadership organisation of profiles, timetables, staffing and communication; problem solving; capacity planning; career-guidance arrangements; use of external expertise. Content and materials: availability and timing of new programmes and teaching/learning materials, taking account of the applicable approbation and textbook-production cycle; UIED approbation and textbook-piloting coverage; actual use in lessons; speed and usefulness of the feedback loop; school/teacher coping strategies where materials are missing or delayed. Infrastructure and resources: subventions and other financing; staffing for specialised hours; psychologist/social-pedagogue functions; equipment delivery, installation, functionality and use; learning spaces, connectivity, power, shelter, transport and boarding/accommodation where relevant. Governance, monitoring and coordination: functioning of NUS Implementation Office and other recurring coordination mechanisms; logging of requests, barriers, decisions and follow-up; data flows; escalation pathways; founder/hromada obligations and problem-solving role; whether evidence feeds into implementation adjustments. Student and family experience: timeliness and clarity of information; orientation, pre-specialisation and counselling; perceived reality and fairness of profile choice and admission; experience of school transition, longer travel or new routines; access barriers and groups most affected. Wherever data permit, the Consultant shall distinguish what was planned or formally provided, what was received, what was operational or usable, and what was actually used. Structural or contextual variables shall not be collapsed into a simple performance or fidelity score unless the Consultant demonstrates a valid measurement approach and obtains Client approval. B.3. Primary stakeholder research and direct verification (Component 3) The Consultant shall collect primary evidence sufficient to verify implementation and explain stakeholder experience where administrative reporting is incomplete or cannot establish actual use or practice. Primary data collection shall complement, not duplicate, existing monitoring. Quantitative stakeholder research. The Consultant shall implement an early implementation survey round and a follow-up survey round during the contract period, aligned with the school calendar and contract start date. School administration: seek coverage of all 150 pilot schools, with a concise instrument focused on implementation, leadership, staffing, profiles, resources, governance and local constraints. Teachers: use two repeated cross-sectional survey rounds with a statistically and operationally adequate sample across the pilot cohort. The design shall support no more than three priority disaggregation dimensions agreed at inception. It is not required to support statistically powered estimates for every intersection of these dimensions. Students: use two repeated cross-sectional survey rounds with a statistically and operationally adequate sample across the pilot cohort, focused on profile choice, access, course delivery, learning experience, safety, support and transition. The design shall support no more than three priority disaggregation dimensions agreed at inception. It is not required to support statistically powered estimates for every intersection of these dimensions. Parents/caregivers: conduct one round with a targeted quantitative sample to answer questions on information, admission, choice, transition, transport/access and family experience; a full census is not required. Founders/community representatives: conduct one targeted structured data-collection round focused on financing, network decisions, transport/boarding, administrative support and founder-school interaction. All questionnaires shall be concise, role-specific and explicitly mapped to the evaluation matrix. The Consultant shall justify sample sizes, response-rate targets, non-response procedures and any weighting strategy in the Inception Report. School administration shall use a panel (linked) design across the two rounds where feasible. Teacher and student surveys shall use repeated cross-sectional designs. Parents/caregivers and founders shall be covered in one round. The Inception Report shall also define the interval between rounds, the analytical interpretation of change between rounds and, for school administration only where a panel is used, respondent-linkage and attrition procedures. Comparative qualitative case studies. The Consultant shall conduct in-depth comparative case studies in 10 pilot schools selected purposively to represent contrasting implementation contexts. The sampling approach and selection criteria shall be approved at inception, and the final case-study sample shall be confirmed in Deliverable D2 based on early implementation evidence. Replacing a case after fieldwork has started shall be treated as a scope change and require prior Client approval. Any follow-up after the main case-study fieldwork shall be remote and limited to up to five case-study schools; additional in-person visits are outside the mandatory scope unless separately agreed. The technical proposal shall state the planned number of field days per case-study school. Semi-structured interviews with school leaders and relevant leadership-team members. Interviews with representatives of founders/hromadas and, where analytically relevant, oblast or other implementation-support actors. Teacher and student focus groups and/or qualitative interviews in a purposive subset of case-study schools. Targeted parent/caregiver interviews or focus groups only in case-study schools where family experience is directly relevant to understanding information, choice, transition, commuting or access barriers. Document review and verification of local implementation arrangements, including profile offer, curricula/timetables, staffing, admission, career guidance, resource use and local decisions. Where feasible and safe, school walkthroughs and direct verification of implementation conditions directly relevant to the selected case, including learning environments, equipment, or transport/boarding arrangements where applicable. Classroom observation. The Consultant shall use direct lesson/classroom observation to assess whether intended teaching and assessment practices are visible in practice and whether specialised materials, spaces and equipment are being used. The Consultant shall propose the observation approach (existing TEACH instruments complemented by the supplementary track-specific module described below), observer-training procedure and quality-control approach. Indicatively, the assignment should include approximately 20 lesson observations across at least five case-study schools and a range of profiles/subjects, with exact numbers finalised at inception. Classroom observations are intended as comparative case-study and mechanism-verification evidence and shall not be treated as statistically representative of teaching practice across the full 150-school pilot. The Consultant shall review relevant existing observation instruments and datasets generated under parallel initiatives, including LEARN-2.4-TEACH, and shall use or adapt them where methodologically appropriate. Because the Teach Secondary tool does not define track-specific expectations, the Consultant shall develop a concise supplementary observation module that operationalises the intended competency-based and differentiated teaching practices for the basic and advanced tracks, based on the State Standard of profile secondary education and the relevant curricula. The criteria shall be agreed with the Client at inception. A full stand-alone observation protocol is not required. Governance and implementation-support interviews. To assess the support cascade and governance pathway, the Consultant shall conduct a limited purposive set of key-informant interviews with relevant national implementation actors and selected oblast/subnational actors only where directly relevant to a priority mechanism or case study. The interviews shall clarify how coordination, data flows, escalation, decision-making and follow-up operate in practice, including the respective roles of MoES/NUS Implementation Office, oblast-level actors, founders/hromadas and schools. Up to three interviews with relevant teacher-training providers may be included to assess teacher-development delivery and the money-follows-the-teacher mechanism. The sample shall be finalised at inception. Triangulation. All primary evidence shall be triangulated across respondent groups and against administrative, documentary and observational evidence wherever feasible. Self-report alone shall not be treated as sufficient verification when an independent source is reasonably available. B.4. Comparative analysis of implementation variation, mechanisms and assumptions (Component 4) The Consultant shall conduct theory-based comparative analysis of contrasting cases to explain why implementation succeeds or encounters difficulties under different conditions. The analysis shall combine the 150-school system-wide profile with primary evidence from case studies and direct verification. Compare schools with varying levels of relevant enabling conditions to identify factors that consistently distinguish stronger from weaker implementation, while avoiding causal claims not supported by the design. Assess teacher development and principal/school-leadership development as distinct pathways and examine how they interact at school level. Examine school leadership/management capacity as a cross-cutting mechanism rather than treating training completion as a proxy for capacity. Prioritise in-depth testing of the four priority mechanisms defined in Section II: the functioning of money-follows-the-teacher, school management capacitythe adequacy and use of management-track PD, and the speed and usefulness of the materials-approbation feedback loop. Analyse the implementation-support cascade and identify where bottlenecks are flagged, escalated and resolved; whether schools rely first on founders/hromadas or bypass them; and whether recurring coordination produces concrete decisions that reach school leaders and teachers in a timely way. Distinguish implementation-fidelity problems, structural/contextual constraints, legitimate adaptations that preserve core reform intent, adaptations that materially weaken or alter the model, and design assumptions requiring system-level revision. Use contribution analysis and/or process tracing, where appropriate, to test whether the expected mechanism is supported by the sequence and triangulation of available evidence and to consider plausible alternative explanations. B.5. Synthesis, scale-up recommendations and knowledge transfer (Component 5) The Consultant shall synthesise quantitative, qualitative, administrative, documentary and observational evidence into a coherent assessment of implementation and its implications for national scale-up. Provide a clear answer to each of the five key evaluation questions and specific objectives. Identify what is working as intended, what is not, where the implementation chain breaks, and which adaptations appear effective. Classify relevant scale-up conditions into: (i) essential enabling conditions; (ii) constraints that can be compensated through additional support or adaptation; and (iii) structural limits to the current model. Specify which components can be scaled as designed, which require modification, and which require differentiated implementation approaches by context. Differentiate recommendations by responsibility: national policy/implementation bodies, oblast/regional actors where relevant, founders/hromadas, and schools. Prioritise recommendations by urgency and importance and identify actions required before and during national rollout. Identify a limited set of priority indicators and data sources that should continue to be monitored after the evaluation, with suggested owners and frequency. Present and discuss findings with the Client and key stakeholders through an interim learning session and a final dissemination/decision workshop. C. Indicative implementation-variation dimensions The qualitative case-study sample should consider the following dimensions where analytically relevant. Quantitative disaggregation shall be limited to no more than three of these dimensions, agreed at inception.These variables are intended to support explanation and case selection, not to create a simple school ranking: previous participation in the upper-secondary pre-pilot and/or earlier NUS piloting; school leadership and management readiness/capacity; urban, rural and mountainous contexts; actual cohort size and cohort stability between selection and the school year; number and diversity of profiles and clusters offered; only-lyceum versus multiple-lyceum community contexts; school structure (e.g., upper-secondary-only versus broader grade spans); in-person, blended and distance-learning modalities, including displacement and security conditions; boarding, transport and physical accessibility; staffing capacity and student-teacher ratios; infrastructure, equipment, connectivity, shelter capacity and actual use of learning environments; local fiscal/economic capacity; language of instruction or other specific implementation contexts; participation in materials/textbook testing or approbation and availability of profile-relevant materials. D. Research-ethics and data-protection protocol The research-ethics and data-protection protocol referred to in Section VI shall address, at minimum: informed consent and, where applicable, parental/guardian consent and student assent; voluntary participation and the right to withdraw; age-appropriate communication and safeguarding procedures for minors; minimisation of collection of personally identifiable information and sensitive data; anonymisation/de-identification and separation of identifiers from analytical datasets; complete deletion of non-anonymous raw data; secure data transfer, storage and hosting arrangements; roles and responsibilities for data control and processing; access control and access logging; conditions for any cross-border data transfer; controls applicable to subcontractors and subprocessors; security-incident and breach-notification procedures; implementation of the least access principle during storage and transfer procedures;and data-retention and secure-deletion procedures; procedures for reporting findings so that individuals cannot be re-identified; Security protocols for fieldwork in conflict-affected settings and remote research where relevant; compliance with applicable Ukrainian legislation, GDPR, and any additional requirements established by the Client or funder. [1] Subject domains supported by the NUS reform: Ukrainian language and literature, Mathematics, Natural Sciences, Technology, Informatics, Social and Health Education, Civics and History, Arts, and Physical Education.

Documents (1)

  • 📎 download
    Download
    The source didn't let us read this document.
All notice detailsShow ↓
Posted
Nov 20, 2026
Type
Request for Expression of Interest
Category
Request for Expression of Interest
Procurement method
Consultant Qualification Selection
Status
open
Jurisdiction
World Bank
Reference #
OP00482903
Solicitation #
LEARN-1.1-EVAL
Country
Ukraine
Notice Text
REQUEST FOR EXPRESSIONS OF INTEREST (CONSULTING SERVICES - FIRMS SELECTION) &nbsp; &nbsp; Country: Ukraine <
Project Name
Lifting Education Access and Resilience in times of Need in Ukraine Program
Notice Status
Published
Bid Description
Consulting services for the process evaluation of the 150-school pilot of the upper secondary (profile) education reform
Contact Address
10 Beresteiskyi Avenue, Kyiv, 01135, Ukraine
Contact Web Url
https://mon.gov.ua/
Notice Lang Name
English
Procurement Group
CS
Procurement Method Code
CQS
Submission Deadline Time
14:00

This listing is a summary from World Bank's open procurement data. The full solicitation documents are on the source portal.